As stated on the Nutrition Class post I created yesterday, I will be sharing my responses to nutrition topics. This post includes my initial response to a question posted by the professor and comments I made to others’ responses to that same question.
The very first discussion topic in the class was the new Food Guide Pyramid. The professor posted:
“The focus of this discussion is on the new Food Guide Pyramid introduced in Chapter 2 of the textbook (12th edition). After you have read Chapters 1 and 2 in the textbook, visit http://www.mypyramid.gov/ to learn more about this new multi-pronged approach to diet planning.
Formulate your initial post by identifying what you believe is the one major advantage and the one major disadvantage to the MyPyramid.gov site.”
My Initial Response
[ME:] I really like the MyPyramid.gov website. VERY WELL organized. Information is readily available through the provided navigations (top and left).
On the pyramid itself, I like that oils are separated from “solid fats”. In the old little white/yellow dots representing both likely confused more people than it helped.[1][2]
On HUGE shortfall on the website AND the new pyramid is the absence of recommending nutritional supplements. Another problem I see is that without spending a lot of time on the site or a lot of time reading our textbook, very few people would understand the recommended servings in the new pyramid.
It is my opinion, the government has done a horrible job at guiding us in the quest for health. Many others share my opinion. So much so that a few years back Harvard researchers published their own pyramid… BASED ON SCIENCE.[3]
According to a Boston newspaper, the government revised the pyramid and confused the public. Harvard “set out to create a guide to good nutrition that uses the familiar pyramid shape but incorporates current research findings”.[4]
I have done my best to follow Harvard’s recommendations since it was first made public (which include multivitamins due to lack of nutrients currently found in green-picked & processed foods, and emphasizes exercise, weight control, and small portions by placing these at the base).
References:
[1] New Pyramid: Textbook, pg 45
[2] Old Pyramid: http://web.mit.edu/athletics/sportsmedicine/Food%20Pyramid.JPG
[3] Harvard Pyramid: http://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/what-should-you-eat/pyramid/
[4] Boston Newspaper: http://www.boston.com/news/health/blog/2008/05/harvards_new_fo.html
Discussion Based on my Initial Response
[STUDENT 1:] Hi Kevin,
I agree that it would be beneficial for the website to mention supplements as they are a big part of the diet for many, and I think that more people take them than not. It can be difficult to meet the recommended intakes on a busy schedule and supplements definitely help in that area. I tend to lean towards your idea that the government has misguided us in our quest for healthy eating, I also believe that they have a lot of incentive from the different food industries to tell us things are healthy and needed when they are not. I didn’t know that Harvard created their own pyramid but I find that interesting and will have to check it out.
[ME:] I remember seeing a presentation that said Kraft foods CEO was working at USDA and was one of the people who put the old pyramid together…
Suggesting, of course that the pyramid was actually set up to drive consumption of their products. I will have to find it. If I am not mistaken, it was by some faculty member at a Texan university.
My Comments on Other Students’ Responses
(First Conversation)
[STUDENT 1:] An advantage to http://www.mypyramid.gov/ is that it has almost all of the information an everyday person would need to know about their nutrition. They can put what they eat in and it will tell them everything they need to know. It is convenient. A disadvantage would be this site does not mention other ways to be healthy or have links to other ways of being healthy like exercising, etc.
[ME:] I completely agree!
Although the pyramid itself has a person walking up the steps, the site lacks guidance.
I found their “Physical activity” recommendations as follows:
Go to http://www.mypyramid.gov
Click “Get weight loss information” link on the right
Scroll down and click on the “Physical activity” link in the 4th step.
But even this page only has 4 links.. 2 of which direct users to more information (1 on tips and another on the importance of exercise). The other two are to the food pyramid and to a generic info page about calories being burned.
Please Join In
Please continue these discussions by adding your comment below.

















